With electric vehicle (EV) charging becoming an increasingly common feature of new-build developments, are we overlooking the risk of simultaneous contact?
As EV charging becomes standard on new-build residential developments, electrical designers and installers must consider an often-overlooked risk: the possibility of simultaneously touching two vehicles connected to separate electrical installations.
Dave Austin and I started looking into the risk at the start of the year so we could update contractors who attended one of our CEF TechTalks. Now I’ve seen others question whether EV chargers installed in close proximity from different electrical supplies pose a risk.
I recently witnessed a situation on a new-build housing development where every property had been provided with an EV charging point. Many chargers were positioned away from their respective dwellings, with some located less than three metres from chargers serving neighbouring properties. Although each charger was supplied by its own dedicated final circuit, the supplies originated from two separate dwellings. This raised an interesting question: could someone touching both vehicles simultaneously be exposed to a dangerous potential difference?
Understanding the electrical risk
Where two properties are supplied by the same low-voltage distribution network, they may share a common TN-C-S (PME) earthing system. However, this does not necessarily mean the exposed-conductive-parts of both charging installations will always be at identical potentials. Each final circuit has its own protective conductor, with resistance and impedance determined by conductor size, length and installation conditions. These differences do not automatically create a voltage difference between vehicles and their chargers. Under normal conditions, protective conductors carry negligible current, meaning differences in their resistance alone should not produce significant touch voltages.
The concern arises when fault currents, diverted neutral currents or other abnormal conditions create voltage drops within the protective conductor or earthing network. Under these circumstances, the conductive bodywork of vehicles connected to different installations could be raised to different potentials. A person simultaneously touching both vehicles could provide a path for current between those potentials, potentially resulting in electric shock.
What does BS 7671 say?
Regulation 411.3.1.1 of BS 7671 requires simultaneously accessible exposed-conductive-parts to be connected to the same earthing system.
Section 722 introduces additional requirements for EV charging installations, particularly concerning the use of PME earthing arrangements and protection against open-PEN conductor conditions.
However, compliance with the requirements for an individual charging point does not automatically demonstrate that simultaneous-contact risks between neighbouring charging installations have been adequately considered. Furthermore, the presence of 30 mA RCD protection or open-PEN detection should not be assumed to eliminate every possible hazardous potential difference between vehicles. This was covered in a recently published IET article on the subject.
Designers of new developments must consider the wider installation and risks of their designs on the electrical systems. The increasing popularity of remote parking spaces, shared driveways and closely positioned EV chargers makes this an important design consideration. Electrical designers should establish the earthing arrangements, assess foreseeable simultaneous contact and consider fault conditions that could introduce hazardous touch voltages.
Where necessary, appropriate protective measures such as separation should be incorporated into the design rather than relying solely on the compliance of individual charging circuits.
Conclusion
I think the message is simple: designing a compliant EV charging circuit is important, but understanding how neighbouring installations interact is equally essential.
As residential EV charging continues to expand, simultaneous-contact risks deserve greater attention during the electrical design process. We need to educate new-build developers so our new residential spaces work with us, not against us.
Have a question or industry comment? Darren is here to provide expert technical advice and answer your queries. Send your questions to info@electrotechnicalnews.com